Amy Lien and Enzo Camacho have been collaborating for more than 12 years, their shared practice is oriented around intensive first-hand research into the impact of globalism, capital and development on specific small-scale communities. Since 2018, they have made a number of works based on the sugar plantations on the island of Negros in the Philippines. Established during the Spanish colonial period, the plantations reinforce an entrenched and brutal class system.

One of the best known sugar manufacturers on Negros is the Victorias Milling Company. In 1950, the company commissioned the Filipino-American modernist painter Alfonso Ossorio, the son of the company’s founder, to create a mural in a chapel servicing the workers of the sugar mill. Powerful and unsettling, yet widely loved and admired, it is popularly referred to as the Angry Christ. For Lien and Camacho, Ossorio’s mural resonates with much of the latent violence and oppression of the plantation system through its radical reworking of Catholic sentiment. Its central figure, with fiery eyes and outstretched arms, appears flayed, his clothing more like skin, muscle and sinew, his heart wrapped in thorns and flames, and a snake and skull lie at his feet.[1]

Watch | Installation time-lapse

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021

For ‘The 10th Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art’ (APT10), Lien and Camacho created a group of interrelated works that spin out from the mural to explore the implications of the global plantation system, and its roots in a dehumanised market economy that has given rise to many forms of contemporary violence and accelerated environmental threat.

Amy Lien; Enzo Camacho ‘The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation)’ 2021

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 / Foldable wooden structure with ink-painted rice paper insets / Central panel: 307 x 307cm; wing panels: 307 x 153.5cm (each) / Handmade papers: Burning Bush 2020; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, wood ash; 43.2 x 25.4cm / Inflammation 2020; Watercolour, gouache, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, oyster shell; 48.3 x 33cm / Martyrs 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, bark, gold leaf; 44.5 x 31.8cm / Riddle 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, joss paper, banana peel, scallions; 20.3 x 33cm / The Plot 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, algae, coconut husk, rice hull, gold Leaf; Triptych: Left panel: 41.9 x 29.2cm; central panel: 45.7 x 32.4cm; right panel: 39.4 x 30.5cm / Tiempo Muerto 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel, scallions, onion skins; 33 x 22.9cm / Under Ground 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel; 34.9 x 25.4cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 / Foldable wooden structure with ink-painted rice paper insets / Central panel: 307 x 307cm; wing panels: 307 x 153.5cm (each) / Handmade papers: Burning Bush 2020; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, wood ash; 43.2 x 25.4cm / Inflammation 2020; Watercolour, gouache, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, oyster shell; 48.3 x 33cm / Martyrs 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, bark, gold leaf; 44.5 x 31.8cm / Riddle 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, joss paper, banana peel, scallions; 20.3 x 33cm / The Plot 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, algae, coconut husk, rice hull, gold Leaf; Triptych: Left panel: 41.9 x 29.2cm; central panel: 45.7 x 32.4cm; right panel: 39.4 x 30.5cm / Tiempo Muerto 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel, scallions, onion skins; 33 x 22.9cm / Under Ground 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel; 34.9 x 25.4cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA / View full image

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 / Foldable wooden structure with ink-painted rice paper insets / Central panel: 307 x 307cm; wing panels: 307 x 153.5cm (each) / Handmade papers: Burning Bush 2020; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, wood ash; 43.2 x 25.4cm / Inflammation 2020; Watercolour, gouache, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, oyster shell; 48.3 x 33cm / Martyrs 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, bark, gold leaf; 44.5 x 31.8cm / Riddle 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, joss paper, banana peel, scallions; 20.3 x 33cm / The Plot 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, algae, coconut husk, rice hull, gold Leaf; Triptych: Left panel: 41.9 x 29.2cm; central panel: 45.7 x 32.4cm; right panel: 39.4 x 30.5cm / Tiempo Muerto 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel, scallions, onion skins; 33 x 22.9cm / Under Ground 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel; 34.9 x 25.4cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 / Foldable wooden structure with ink-painted rice paper insets / Central panel: 307 x 307cm; wing panels: 307 x 153.5cm (each) / Handmade papers: Burning Bush 2020; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, wood ash; 43.2 x 25.4cm / Inflammation 2020; Watercolour, gouache, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, oyster shell; 48.3 x 33cm / Martyrs 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, bark, gold leaf; 44.5 x 31.8cm / Riddle 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, joss paper, banana peel, scallions; 20.3 x 33cm / The Plot 2021; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, algae, coconut husk, rice hull, gold Leaf; Triptych: Left panel: 41.9 x 29.2cm; central panel: 45.7 x 32.4cm; right panel: 39.4 x 30.5cm / Tiempo Muerto 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel, scallions, onion skins; 33 x 22.9cm / Under Ground 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel; 34.9 x 25.4cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA / View full image

The centrepiece, The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021, is a re-imagined folding altarpiece or retable, constructed from raw timber and inset with inked rice paper paintings showing details from Ossorio’s mural and the artists’ own photographs of workers harvesting cane by hand. The fragmented images imply a painterly metanarrative of cutting and piecing echoed in the steel blades of the knives held by the depicted workers. The retable itself, with its folding wings, implies ‘motion, mutability, transformation’ and, in the artists’ words, takes ‘the existing mural off of the wall, reactivating it by “folding it out” in different directions’.[2]

Construction of the folding altarpiece

Construction of The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 by Amy Lien and Enzo Camacho / Photograph: C Callistermon © QAGOMA

Construction of The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 by Amy Lien and Enzo Camacho / Photograph: C Callistermon © QAGOMA / View full image

Construction of The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 by Amy Lien and Enzo Camacho / Photograph: C Callistermon © QAGOMA

Construction of The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 by Amy Lien and Enzo Camacho / Photograph: C Callistermon © QAGOMA / View full image

Operating in conjunction with the folding retable are a group of ‘handmade papers’. These works are made with sugarcane fibres from Negros, combined with a range of other materials including wax, watercolour or gouache, coconut and rice hulls, seaweed, wood ash, abaca, corn husk, banana peel, scallions and onion skins.[3] In creating these works, Lien and Camacho were inspired by theorist Sylvia Wynter and her discussion of the garden plots planted by African slaves in the Caribbean as the sites of eventual ‘cultural guerilla resistance’.[4] These works take up the concerns of plot and plantation by indexing the sugar ecology of Negros and suggesting alternative narratives.

While many of the symbols in their drawings are structured around references to Ossorio’s mural — the skull, snake, the flaming heart — the artists have introduced one element not employed by Ossorio. The body of a lion surrounded by a swarm of bees is taken from the Old Testament biblical narrative in which Samson finds a beehive in a lion‘s carcass, and collects some honey to eat. He created a riddle arising from this experience: ‘Out of the eater, something to eat; out of the strong, something sweet’.[5] After adopting this symbol of transformation, the artists later discovered it had been appropriated as a logo in the 1880s by the British sugar-refining company Abram Lyle & Sons. This riddle within a riddle echoes the ongoing potential of Lien and Camacho’s works to generate new meanings and to delve deeper into the insurgent potential of art.

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / Under Ground 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel; 34.9 x 25.4cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / Under Ground 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel; 34.9 x 25.4cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA / View full image

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / Burning Bush 2020; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, wood ash; 43.2 x 25.4cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / Burning Bush 2020; Watercolour, gouache, ink, wax, cotton, bagasse, wood ash; 43.2 x 25.4cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA / View full image

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / Inflammation 2020; Watercolour, gouache, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, oyster shell; 48.3 x 33cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / Inflammation 2020; Watercolour, gouache, wax, cotton, bagasse, seaweed, oyster shell; 48.3 x 33cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA / View full image

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / Tiempo Muerto 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel, scallions, onion skins; 33 x 22.9cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA

Amy Lien, United States b.1987; Enzo Camacho, The Philippines b.1985 / Tiempo Muerto 2021; Watercolour, gouache, wax, abaca, corn husk, banana peel, scallions, onion skins; 33 x 22.9cm / Courtesy and ©: The artists / Photograph: N Harth © QAGOMA / View full image

Abigail Bernal is Associate Curator, Asian Art, QAGOMA
This is an edited extract from the QAGOMA publication The 10th Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art available in-store and online from the QAGOMA Store.


The 10th Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art’ / Queensland Art Gallery and Gallery of Modern Art, Brisbane / 4 December 2021 to 25 April 2022

Supported by the Australian Government through the Office for the Arts.

Featured image: Amy Lien and Enzo Camacho / The Angry Christ (Plot and Plantation) 2021 / Foldable wooden structure with ink-painted rice paper insets with Riddle 2021 highlighted / Photograph: J Ruckli © QAGOMA
#APT10QAGOMA #QAGOMA

Endnotes

  1. ^ Their initial research was presented as an artist lecture and mural for the NTU Center for Contemporary Art in Singapore (2019), and subsequently as a mural and group of works on paper at SOAS University of London.
  2. ^ Amy Lien and Enzo Camacho, email to the author, 18 March 2021.
  3. ^ The drawings take as their point of departure Ossorio’s series of wax-resist ‘Victorias Drawings’.
  4. ^ Sylvia Wynter, ‘Novel and history, plot and plantation’, Savacou, no.5, June 1971, pp.95–102.
  5. ^ The answer, composed like a riddle itself, is ‘What is sweeter than honey? What is stronger than a lion?’

Related Stories

  • Read

    ‘The fibrous souls’ installation constructed with 70 giant shikas

    The fibrous souls 2018–21 currently in the Queensland Art Gallery Watermall is constructed with 70 giant shikas — embroidered, reticulated bags typically made of jute strings that are tied to a beam in the ceiling of houses and used to hold pots and food containers — Shikas are found in almost every house in rural Bangladesh and are traditionally made at home by families. Their designs, knotting and decoration varies between regions. Kamruzzaman Shadhin and Gidree Bawlee Foundation of Arts expansive installation focuses on a part of Bengal’s complex and pervasive colonial history through personal stories of movement and displacement, the artwork articulates how a small part of the community came to settle in the surrounding villages. Watch | Installation time-lapse Kamruzzaman Shadhin, Bangladesh b.1974 / Gidree Bawlee Foundation of Arts, Bangladesh, est. 2001; Collaborating artists: Johura Begum, Monowara Begum, Majeda Begum, Fatema Begum (1), Shabnur Begum, Chayna Begum, Fatema Begum (2), Samiron Begum, Shirina Begum, Rekha, Nasima Begum, Shushila Rani, Protima Rani, Akalu Barman / The fibrous souls 2018–21 / Jute, cotton, thread, clay, brass / 70 pots: 40–100cm each (diam.) (approx.) with 70 shikas of various dimensions / Originally commissioned by Samdani Art Foundation / Purchased 2021 with funds from Metamorphic Foundation through the Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Art Foundation / Collection: Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Art, Brisbane / © The artists Stories that inspired the artwork are drawn from families that had followed the railway tracks from what is now Bangladesh into India, after the British East India Company established the Eastern Bengal Railway. Operating under British Indian rule from 1892 to 1942, the railway served the profiteering trade interests of British India, fuelled by locally produced commodities such as jute, indigo and opium. The domination of these cash crops led to food scarcity, debt and land loss, forcing people — such as the ancestors of the Thakurgaon jute makers — to turn away from farming their own lands. Families gradually left their homes to follow opportunities along the railway to Assam; however, during the 1947 Partition of India, they found themselves separated from their homes by a new national border, only to be forced back over from India into what had become East Pakistan (present-day Bangladesh). They settled along the Brahmaputra River in the regions by the new border dividing Bengal. As this vast river continually eroded, their plight turned from political to ecological migration, slowly moving westwards until they settled in Thakurgaon. Over more than 20 years, Kamruzzaman Shadhin has developed new possibilities for contemporary art in Bangladesh, centred around the communities of his home village of Balia in the far north-western state of Thakurgaon. In 2001, he established Gidree Bawlee Foundation of Arts to work with local indigenous Santhal communities. The foundation seeks to be a catalyst for social inclusivity through collaborative approaches. Shadhin is also one of Bangladesh’s foremost contemporary artists, known for his installations and performances that address environmental and social issues, particularly those facing regional Bangladesh and its communities. Together with Gidree Bawlee Foundation of Arts, he produces ambitious contemporary art projects, driven by the principles of community development and exploring shared culture and histories. Working with 13 women hailing from jute-making families to construct the shikas, along with a handful of other local craftspeople to create the pots and connecting jute ropes, Shadhin and Gidree Bawlee Foundation of Arts have constructed a giant hanging system of shikas, laid out as the map of the historic Eastern Bengal Railway that began this story. The women created their own designs on the shikas, so each is unique and features various wrapping and knotting techniques and additional decoration. The shikas hold brass, jute and clay storage pots, which are suspended over water for APT10. The hanging pots each symbolise the stations of towns and cities on the railway map — from Calcutta (now Kolkata) and Chittagong (now Chattogram) in the south, to Darjeeling and Guwahati in the north — signifying the defining role this piece of colonial infrastructure has played in shaping their lives. In Shadhin’s words, the installation is an attempt to interweave these historical and cultural strands that seem apparently and innocently disconnected, and connect these to the present-day peasant conditions in Assam and Bengal. The project draws together members of communities to explore their own stories and cultural practices — and is a product of the unique practice Shadhin and Gidree Bawlee Foundation of Arts have developed. Imbued with local and social values, it is a practice that advocates and finds in regional communities new pathways for contemporary art that are not reliant on art centres or global arts discourse, revealing new possibilities for art production to audiences far from where they emerge. Tarun Nagesh is Curatorial Manager, Asian and Pacific Art, QAGOMA This is an edited extract from the QAGOMA publication The 10th Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art available in-store and online from the QAGOMA Store.
  • Read

    Installation is a layering of sound, visuals & mechanics

    A Diasporic Mythology 2021 is a kinetic and sound installation commissioned for ‘The 10th Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art’ (APT10) and developed from Bagus Pandega’s interest in the historical narratives and circulation of instruments. The artist became fascinated with a particular koto instrument, named a Taishogoto, dating to the Taisho period (1912–26), that he stumbled across in Japan. This particular historical version of the stringed instrument (also known as the Nagoya harp) was developed by a musician in Nagoya and varied greatly in design from the classical koto by incorporating automation, through typewriter-like keys, influenced by Western music structures. Its popularity was fleeting, although it had a considerable influence on instruments outside of Japan at the time, and the instrument is seldom used today. Pandega has also been scouring Indonesia for instruments that directly resemble the Taishogoto but are considered native to their locations and are commonly used in ritual ceremonies. The installation A Diasporic Mythology brings together different examples of these Indonesian instruments — including a Mandaliong, Balinese Penting, Kecapi Sijobang and Lombok Penting — in an arrangement together with a single Japanese Taishogoto. Tea plants are connected to sensors that follow musical notations on a paper roll derived from interviews Pandega conducted with musicians. These then trigger solenoid drivers with a rotating motor attached to each key of the instruments, allowing the score to be played. The tea plants become the centre of the installation and signify a further exploration of historical cultural influence between the two countries: the first tea plants were brought to Indonesia from Japan by the Dutch in the seventeenth century in an attempt to replicate the success of British tea cultivating in India, as part of a trade that would lead to the colonisation of Indonesia. On a tea branch in the centre of the installation a series of LED screens shows close-up footage of performers in Indonesia, which returns the performers to the sounds of the instruments and the local contexts and ritualised space they are associated with locally. A Diasporic Mythology becomes a layering of sound, visuals and mechanics, carefully pieced together by Pandega through a sprawling system of custom-made devices. Yet through all the tangle of connecting apparatus, the artist draws out the fascinating history of these objects and the people, stories and ceremonies that have gradually evolved around them. Watch | Installation time-lapse Bagus Pandega, Indonesia b.1985 / A Diasporic Mythology 2021 / String instruments: Taishogoto, Mandaliong, Balinese Penting, Kecapi Sijobang, Lombok Penting; tea plants (Camellia sinensis), LED screens, motors, solenoids, Midi Sprout, custom electronic and mechanic system, glass jar, vinyl paper, custom 3D-printed parts, zincplated steel, teak wood, copper, acrylic and instrument stand / Commissioned for ‘The 10th Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art’ (APT10) / Courtesy and ©: Bagus Pandega and ROH Projects, Jakarta Watch | Koto performance alongside Bagus Pandega’s APT10 artwork Bagus Pandega Bagus Pandega’s sculptures and installations are a cacophonous web of mechanical, sound, light and automated kinetic constructions. The artist builds objects and devices into modular systems that operate as live and active multi-sensory sculptures, and his works reveal a passion for applied technologies and developing narratives around social contexts. A graduate of the Institut Teknologi Bandung, Pandega is a prominent member of a generation of artists in Bandung who have become known for incorporating technologies and experimental practices in their works, in contrast to other Indonesian art centres that are commonly associated with paradigms of representational, political and collective practices. Pandega offers new ways to navigate objects and their intended utility, creating layered sound and visual experiences activated by custom-made electronics. A sense of simplicity underlies the complex set-ups, however, with wiring and older, pre-digital technologies left deliberately exposed. Each work gives considered focus to particular devices — lights, screens, amplifiers, instruments — as Pandega refines the ways they operate around a nexus of systems. Cheap and everyday technologies, such as amassed motorcycle lights, beacons, megaphones, small rotating motors, circuit boards and basic LED matrix screens are combined with industrial and machine materials, toys, instruments and cymbal stands from drumkits. Recent works have also introduced natural materials, carefully selected not only to contribute to the narrative that underlies the works but also for their biological energy and mechanical triggering potential. Plants and flowers are incorporated in installations, connected through MIDI sprouts — which convert biodata from plants into music — to trigger instruments and mechanics. Tarun Nagesh is Curatorial Manager, Asian and Pacific Art, QAGOMA This is an edited extract from the QAGOMA publication The 10th Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art available in-store and online from the QAGOMA Store.